You would think that as a couple, you can always be in the same room when you are recording. We found out recently, that isn’t always the case. One of us was sick and had to be isolated, but the show must go on! We recorded the episode on Streamyard, and when we finished, we were worried that the chemistry woudn’t be the same if we weren’t looking at each other, anticipating the other’s reaction, or feeling emotional shifts. It made us wonder, what are the pros and cons of recording in person versus recording on Zoom or Streamyard?
In this blog post, we’ll look into the pros and cons of both options to help you decide how you want to record your podcast.
Recording In Person
Pros:
- Real Connection and Non-Verbal Communication: When we sit together and record, we can feel when the other person is going to laugh, can see when they are truly shocked or surprised, and if they are excited about a topic. As you have probably seen on in-person podcasts with video, in-person recordings often result in a more genuine and personal connection between the host and the guest. The chemistry and rapport that can develop face-to-face can lead to more engaging and natural conversations. Being in the same room allows for non-verbal cues like body language and facial expressions to play a more significant role in the conversation, adding depth and nuance to the content.
- Quality Audio: We use one microphone, and sit across from each other or side by side to record. We can both see our levels and make sure we are both loud enough (or not too loud) In-person recording typically results in better audio quality with fewer technical glitches or audio artifacts. We can control the environment and equipment, ensuring a clear recording.
- Unique Content: Since we record in person most of the time, we can diversify our content based on where we are. We just have to have our equipment, which sometimes is only a cell phone and lapel mics, and we can make video and audio content. Some podcasts, especially those involving hands-on demonstrations or location-based content, can only be recorded in person and serve as unique opportunities to make audio and video content.
Cons:
- Logistics: We record before work, but sometimes we have to travel separately. Our audience wants consistency from us, so we can’t always record in person.
- Location Limitations: If you have guests, your guest may not be geographically accessible, limiting your potential pool of guests. This can be especially challenging for niche or specialized topics. Your expert may not be located anywhere near you.
- Your Technical Setup: We happen to have a pretty simple setup with just one microphone. In other cases, if you aren’t recording with your spouse, close friend, or close relative, in-person recording means you will need more advanced technical equipment and setup, which can be tough for beginners or those on a tight budget.
- Noise and Distractions: There is a train that runs RIGHT next to the place where we record. We know when that is coming, and it still is a distraction. Imagine recording in a place where you aren’t familiar with the noises, and they aren’t on a schedule like a train. Recording in an unfamiliar location (or even a familiar one) can introduce unexpected background noise and distractions that might not occur in a controlled podcast studio environment. Side note: Check your with your local government to see if they have free or low cost podcast studio space that you can use. You may even be able to use their equipment.
In podcasting, each show comes with its unique set of objectives, content, and available resources. Whether you opt for in-person recordings or go virtual using platforms like Zoom or Streamyard, the choice hinges on your podcasting blueprint and technical setup. Both avenues boast their own merits and drawbacks. Ask yourself, how does each option align with your podcasting vision, practicalities, and capabilities. Some podcasters, when the situation demands it, adopt a hybrid strategy, seamlessly blending the best of both worlds. Don’t forget that the excellence of your content and the richness of your discussions should be at the forefront of your podcasting priorities, no matter which option you choose.
Continue reading – Part 2: The Pros and Cons of Recording a Podcast with Guests In Person vs. Recording on Zoom or StreamYard
